Characterization of waste - Framework for the preparation and application of a testing programme - Objectives, planning and report

EN 16457:2014 specifies requirements for a waste testing programme regarding mainly objectives, planning and report with the intent to ensure reliable and comparable results when using the reference methods that have been developed and/or adopted by CEN/TC 292. The planning and report aspects of this European Standard are applicable to any waste testing programme dedicated to the determination of one or several parameters. They are also applicable to all testing steps for each parameter from sampling up to reporting whether these steps are taking place in the field (e.g. sampling) or in the laboratory (e.g. analysis-quantification). This European Standard does not address aspects of safety for activities in the field and inside laboratory.

Charakterisierung von Abfällen - Rahmen für die Vorbereitung und Anwendung eines Untersuchungsprogramms - Ziele, Planung und Bericht

Die vorliegende Europäische Norm legt Anforderungen an ein Untersuchungsprogramm für Abfälle fest, wobei hauptsächlich Ziele, Planung und Bericht behandelt werden, um bei der Anwendung der vom CEN/TC 292 entwickelten und/oder angenommenen Bezugsverfahren zuverlässige und vergleichbare Ergebnisse sicherzu¬stellen.
Die auf die Planung und Berichterstattung bezogenen Aspekte dieser Europäischen Norm gelten für jedes Untersuchungsprogramm für Abfälle, das für die Bestimmung eines oder mehrerer Parameter(s) vorgesehen ist. Sie gelten darüber hinaus für sämtliche Untersuchungsschritte für jeden Parameter von der Probenahme bis zur Berichterstattung, unabhängig davon, ob diese Schritte vor Ort (z. B. Probenahme) oder im Laboratorium (z. B. Analyse/quantitative Bestimmung) stattfinden.
ANMERKUNG   Der Ausdruck „Planung eines Untersuchungsprogramms“ wird hier in der allgemeinen Bedeutung der Organisation eines Untersuchungsprogramms und in Übereinstimmung mit den in der vorliegenden Europäischen Norm verwendeten Begriffen „Untersuchungsplan“, „Probenahmeplan“ und „Laboratoriumsplan“ verwendet.
Diese Europäische Norm behandelt keine Aspekte der Sicherheit im Zusammenhang mit Tätigkeiten vor Ort und im Laboratorium.

Caractérisation des déchets - Procédure-cadre pour l'élaboration et la mise en oeuvre d'un programme d'essai - Objectifs, planification et rapport

La présente Norme européenne spécifie les exigences relatives à un programme d’essai de déchets, notamment en ce qui concerne les objectifs, la planification et le rapport, dans le but de garantir la fiabilité et la comparabilité des résultats en utilisant les méthodes de référence qui ont été élaborées et/ou adoptées par le CEN/TC 292.
Les aspects de la présente Norme européenne relatifs à la planification et au rapport s’appliquent à tout programme d’essai de déchets visant à déterminer un ou plusieurs paramètres. Ils s’appliquent également à toutes les étapes d’essai portant sur chaque paramètre, de l’échantillonnage à la production du rapport, que ces étapes se déroulent sur le terrain (par exemple, échantillonnage) ou en laboratoire (par exemple, analyse-quantification).
NOTE   L’expression « planification d’un programme d’essai » revêt ici le sens général d’organiser un programme d’essai en étant en accord avec les termes « plan d’essai », « plan d’échantillonnage », « plan de laboratoire » utilisés dans la présente Norme européenne.
La présente Norme européenne ne traite pas les aspects liés à la sécurité des activités menées sur le terrain et en laboratoire.

Karakterizacija odpadkov - Okvirno navodilo za pripravo in uporabo programa preskušanja - Cilji, načrtovanje in poročanje

Standard EN 16457:2014 določa zahteve za program preskušanja odpadkov, ki zadevajo predvsem cilje, načrtovanje in poročanje, z namenom zagotavljanja zanesljivih in primerljivih rezultatov pri uporabi referenčnih metod, ki jih je razvil in/ali jih uporablja CEN/TC 292. Načrtovanje in poročanje, kot ju določa ta evropski standard, se lahko uporabljata za kateri koli program preskušanja odpadkov, katerega cilj je določevanje enega ali več parametrov. Prav tako se lahko uporabljata za vse preskusne korake pri vsakem parametru od vzorčenja do poročanja, ne glede na to, ali se ti koraki izvajajo na terenu (npr. vzorčenje) ali laboratoriju (npr. analiza-kvantifikacija). Ta evropski standard ne obravnava varnostnih vidikov za dejavnosti, ki se izvajajo na terenu ali v laboratoriju.

General Information

Status
Published
Public Enquiry End Date
14-Nov-2012
Publication Date
09-Jun-2014
Technical Committee
Current Stage
6060 - National Implementation/Publication (Adopted Project)
Start Date
29-May-2014
Due Date
03-Aug-2014
Completion Date
10-Jun-2014

Buy Standard

Standard
EN 16457:2014 - BARVE
English language
26 pages
sale 10% off
Preview
sale 10% off
Preview
e-Library read for
1 day
Draft
prEN 16457:2012
English language
24 pages
sale 10% off
Preview
sale 10% off
Preview
e-Library read for
1 day

Standards Content (Sample)

2003-01.Slovenski inštitut za standardizacijo. Razmnoževanje celote ali delov tega standarda ni dovoljeno.Charakterisierung von Abfällen - Rahmen für die Vorbereitung und Anwendung eines Untersuchungsprogramms - Ziele, Planung und BerichtCaractérisation des déchets - Procédure-cadre pour l'élaboration et la mise en oeuvre d'un programme d'essai - Objectifs, planification et rapportCharacterization of waste - Framework for the preparation and application of a testing programme - Objectives, planning and report13.030.01Odpadki na splošnoWastes in generalICS:Ta slovenski standard je istoveten z:EN 16457:2014SIST EN 16457:2014en,fr,de01-julij-2014SIST EN 16457:2014SLOVENSKI
STANDARD



SIST EN 16457:2014



EUROPEAN STANDARD NORME EUROPÉENNE EUROPÄISCHE NORM
EN 16457
March 2014 ICS 13.030.01 English Version
Characterization of waste - Framework for the preparation and application of a testing programme - Objectives, planning and report
Caractérisation des déchets - Procédure-cadre pour l'élaboration et la mise en oeuvre d'un programme d'essai -Objectifs, planification et rapport
Charakterisierung von Abfällen - Rahmenbedingungen für die Vorbereitung und Anwendung eines Untersuchungsprogramms - Ziele, Planung und Bericht This European Standard was approved by CEN on 20 December 2013.
CEN members are bound to comply with the CEN/CENELEC Internal Regulations which stipulate the conditions for giving this European Standard the status of a national standard without any alteration. Up-to-date lists and bibliographical references concerning such national standards may be obtained on application to the CEN-CENELEC Management Centre or to any CEN member.
This European Standard exists in three official versions (English, French, German). A version in any other language made by translation under the responsibility of a CEN member into its own language and notified to the CEN-CENELEC Management Centre has the same status as the official versions.
CEN members are the national standards bodies of Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Iceland, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey and United Kingdom.
EUROPEAN COMMITTEE FOR STANDARDIZATION
COMITÉ EUROPÉEN DE NORMALISATION EUROPÄISCHES KOMITEE FÜR NORMUNG
CEN-CENELEC Management Centre:
Avenue Marnix 17,
B-1000 Brussels © 2014 CEN All rights of exploitation in any form and by any means reserved worldwide for CEN national Members. Ref. No. EN 16457:2014 ESIST EN 16457:2014



EN 16457:2014 (E)
2
Contents Page Foreword .3 Introduction .4 1 Scope .5 2 Normative references .5 3 Terms and definitions.7 4 Defining a waste testing programme .9 4.1 Principles .9 4.2 Structure of a waste testing programme .10 4.3 Parameters to be tested for a waste .12 4.4 Responsibilities and programme manager .13 4.5 Standards to be used .14 5 Carrying out a waste testing programme .15 6 Overall testing report .15 Annex A (normative)
Matrix testing steps versus parameters specifying the standards to be used in a waste testing programme .17 Annex B (informative)
A-deviations .25 Bibliography .26
SIST EN 16457:2014



EN 16457:2014 (E) 3
Foreword This document (EN 16457:2014) has been prepared by Technical Committee CEN/TC 292 “Characterization of waste”, the secretariat of which is held by NEN. This European Standard shall be given the status of a national standard, either by publication of an identical text or by endorsement, at the latest by September 2014 and conflicting national standards shall be withdrawn at the latest by September 2014. Attention is drawn to the possibility that some of the elements of this document may be the subject of patent rights. CEN [and/or CENELEC] shall not be held responsible for identifying any or all such patent rights. It is to be noted that for Germany an A-deviation applies (see Annex B). This document has been prepared by the ad hoc group “Testing programme” of CEN/TC 292. It has been decided by CEN/TC 292 to prepare the present document and to consider separately other issues supporting this document. This would finally result in a set of four documents on waste testing as listed in the Introduction. According to the CEN-CENELEC Internal Regulations, the national standards organizations of the following countries are bound to implement this European Standard: Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Iceland, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey and the United Kingdom. SIST EN 16457:2014



EN 16457:2014 (E)
4
Introduction This European Standard was elaborated as a help for those who have to organize and apply a waste testing programme. Often several parameters need to be determined in a waste sample and for each parameter different testing steps of a different nature need to be coordinated and performed. This is done in accordance with dedicated standards developed by CEN/TC 292 (e.g. standards for the steps of sampling, extraction, leaching and analysis of eluates or extracts). In order to cope with these different parameters to be tested and with these different testing steps of different nature, the testing of a waste generally refers to different standards which should be used (and elaborated) in a coherent and coordinated way in a testing programme. This European Standard is designed for specifying such overall testing programmes. This European Standard may be used by different interested parties in waste testing: plant operators, testing institutes, accreditation bodies, etc. as well as by industries to address the waste testing part of their contracts and by regulators to address the waste testing part of their regulations. This European Standard can be used to: — produce a standardized testing programme for use in regular or routine circumstances (elaboration of daughter/derived standards dedicated to well defined testing scenarios); — incorporate the specific testing requirements of European and national legislation; — design and develop a waste testing programme for use on a case by case basis. This European Standard provides requirements on the programme, objective, plan and report for the execution of a waste testing programme. This is done with the intent to ensure reliable and comparable results when using the reference methods that have been developed by CEN/TC 292 in accordance with the principles specified in this standard and in the supporting documents (listed below). As shown in Figures 2 and 3, for waste testing, the tests to be performed consist (see also the supporting documents listed below) of two main works: the sampling in the field and the analysis-quantification in the laboratory. The needed coordination and interface is the responsibility of the programme manager (see 4.4). It is also the responsibility of the programme manager to design the testing programme, to authorize the testing report and to submit it to the customer. This European Standard includes one normative annex and one informative annex which are part of this standard. This European Standard is intended to become a part of a set of documents consisting of the present document: — EN 16457, Characterization of waste – Framework for the preparation and application of a testing programme – Objective, planning and report and of three supporting documents providing important information: — CEN/TS (WI 00292082), Characterization of waste – Framework for the preparation and application of a testing programme – Application of EN ISO/IEC 17025 (in preparation) — CEN/TS (WI 00292085), Characterization of waste – Framework for the preparation and application of a testing programme – Guidelines for the elaboration of standardised testing methods (in preparation) — CEN/TR (WI 00292084), Characterization of waste – Framework for the preparation and application of a testing programme – General information on content tests and leaching tests (in preparation) SIST EN 16457:2014



EN 16457:2014 (E) 5
1 Scope This European Standard specifies requirements for a waste testing programme regarding mainly objectives, planning and report with the intent to ensure reliable and comparable results when using the reference methods that have been developed and/or adopted by CEN/TC 292. The planning and report aspects of this European Standard are applicable to any waste testing programme dedicated to the determination of one or several parameters. They are also applicable to all testing steps for each parameter from sampling up to reporting whether these steps are taking place in the field (e.g. sampling) or in the laboratory (e.g. analysis-quantification). This European Standard does not address aspects of safety for activities in the field and inside laboratory. NOTE The term planning a testing programme is used here with the general meaning of organizing a testing programme and being in accordance with the terms testing plan, sampling plan, laboratory plan used in the present European Standard. 2 Normative references The following documents, in whole or in part, are normatively referenced in this document and are indispensable for its application. For dated references, only the edition cited applies. For undated references, the latest edition of the referenced document (including any amendments) applies.1) EN 12457-1, Characterisation of waste - Leaching - Compliance test for leaching of granular waste materials and sludges - Part 1: One stage batch test at a liquid to solid ratio of 2 l/kg for materials with high solid content and with particle size below 4 mm (without or with size reduction) EN 12457-2, Characterisation of waste - Leaching - Compliance test for leaching of granular waste materials and sludges - Part 2: One stage batch test at a liquid to solid ratio of 10 l/kg for materials with particle size below 4 mm (without or with size reduction) EN 12457-3, Characterisation of waste - Leaching - Compliance test for leaching of granular waste materials and sludges - Part 3: Two stage batch test at a liquid to solid ratio of 2 l/kg and 8 l/kg for materials with high solid content and with particle size below 4 mm (without or with size reduction) EN 12457-4, Characterisation of waste - Leaching - Compliance test for leaching of granular waste materials and sludges - Part 4: One stage batch test at a liquid to solid ratio of 10 l/kg for materials with particle size below 10 mm (without or with size reduction) EN 13137, Characterization of waste - Determination of total organic carbon (TOC) in waste, sludges and sediments EN 13656, Characterization of waste - Microwave assisted digestion with hydrofluoric (HF), nitric (HNO3) and hydrochloric (HCl) acid mixture for subsequent determination of elements EN 13657, Characterization of waste - Digestion for subsequent determination of aqua regia soluble portion of elements EN 14039, Characterization of waste - Determination of hydrocarbon content in the range of C10 to C40 by gas chromatography EN 14345, Characterization of waste - Determination of hydrocarbon content by gravimetry
1) Useful information may be found in several CEN/TRs as mentioned in Annex A. The use of CEN/TRs is not mandatory and other sources of information may be used provided that the requirements of the basic EN or CEN/TS are fulfilled. The list of such CEN/TR is given in the Bibliography, references [5] to [15]. SIST EN 16457:2014



EN 16457:2014 (E)
6
EN 14346, Characterization of waste - Calculation of dry matter by determination of dry residue or water content CEN/TS 14405, Characterization of waste - Leaching behaviour tests - Up-flow percolation test (under specified conditions) prEN 14429, Characterisation of waste - Leaching behaviour test - Influence of pH on leaching with initial acid/base addition EN 14582, Characterization of waste - Halogen and sulfur content - Oxygen combustion in closed systems and determination methods EN 14735, Characterization of waste - Preparation of waste samples for ecotoxicity tests EN 14899, Characterization of waste - Sampling of waste materials - Framework for the preparation and application of a Sampling Plan prEN 14997, Characterisation of waste - Leaching behaviour test - Influence of pH on leaching with continuous pH control EN 15002, Characterization of waste - Preparation of test portions from the laboratory sample EN 15169, Characterization of waste - Determination of loss on ignition in waste, sludge and sediments EN 15192, Characterisation of waste and soil - Determination of Chromium(VI) in solid material by alkaline digestion and ion chromatography with spectrophotometric detection EN 15308, Characterization of waste - Determination of selected polychlorinated biphenyls (PCB) in solid waste by using capillary gas chromatography with electron capture or mass spectrometric detection EN 15309, Characterization of waste and soil - Determination of elemental composition by X-ray fluorescence EN 15216, Characterization of waste - Determination of total dissolved solids (TDS) in water and eluates CEN/TS 15364, Characterization of waste - Leaching behaviour tests - Acid and base neutralization capacity test EN 15527, Characterization of waste - Determination of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH) in waste using gas chromatography mass spectrometry (GC/MS) CEN/TS 15862, Characterisation of waste - Compliance leaching test - One stage batch leaching test for monoliths at fixed liquid to surface area ratio (L/A) for test portions with fixed minimum dimensions prEN 15863, Characterisation of waste - Leaching behaviour test for basic characterisation - Dynamic monolithic leaching test with periodic leachant renewal, under fixed conditions CEN/TS 15864, Characterisation of waste - Leaching behaviour test for basic characterisation - Dynamic monolithic leaching test with continuous leachant renewal under conditions relevant for specified scenario(s) EN 15875, Characterization of waste - Static test for determination of acid potential and neutralisation potential of sulfidic waste CEN/TS 16023, Characterization of waste - Determination of gross calorific value and calculation of net calorific value EN 16192, Characterization of waste - Analysis of eluates CEN/TS 16229, Characterization of waste - Sampling and analysis of weak acid dissociable cyanide discharged into tailings ponds EN 16377, Characterization of waste - Determination of brominated flame retardants (BFR) in solid waste SIST EN 16457:2014



EN 16457:2014 (E) 7
3 Terms and definitions For the purposes of this document, the following terms and definitions apply.2) 3.1 additional parameter (AP) parameter that needs to be tested so that the test results could be calculated and/or interpreted Note 1 to entry: For instance, the dry matter for expressing the test results on a dry basis, or pH in eluate to be able to understand and check consistency of test data and to understand/investigate unexpected outcome or unexpected variations. 3.2 analysis / quantification step in the testing programme where the magnitude of the parameters is determined and the obtained data can be directly delivered for final use and reporting or from which the data can be delivered for further calculations EXAMPLE Measuring the length with a measuring tape, measuring the temperature with a thermometer, determining (analysing) the concentrations of substances in an extract or eluate. Note 1 to entry: In the last example, the concentration of the substance in a material or the leachable fraction from a material would be calculated, using the data on the concentrations in the extract or the eluate. 3.3 customer organization or person that orders for a test and that receives the final test report [SOURCE: EN ISO 9000:2005, 3.3.5] 3.4 involved parties individuals and organizations that are directly or indirectly involved in the specification of the testing programme and or in the execution of the programme [SOURCE: EN 14899:2005, 2.7, modified] Note 1 to entry: Such parties include, for instance, the customer, (e.g. the producer or the user of the material), the regulator, a certification body, the sampler, the analyst, the laboratory. The person responsible for the final specification of the testing programme and the final test report is the programme manager. 3.5 laboratory plan plan, which is part of the testing plan, including all the required steps and relevant information pertinent to a particular laboratory activity Note 1 to entry: The laboratory plan includes the preparation of the test sample(s), the extraction, leaching or other activity with the sample(s), analysis, calculations and reporting. Note 2 to entry: The laboratory plan includes specification of the tests to be executed, the laboratory (or laboratories) involved, and the planning.
2) The terms and definitions listed in this clause are needed for the present European Standard with regards to the design and execution of a testing programme. In many other standardized documents useful terms and definitions are available and these will not be repeated here. The supporting document Guidelines for the elaboration of standardized testing methods (in preparation) referred to in the Introduction would consolidate and harmonize the definitions in all CEN/TC 292 standards. SIST EN 16457:2014



EN 16457:2014 (E)
8
3.6 parameter measurable property whose value is a determinant of the characteristics of a waste material Note 1 to entry: For instance, relevant parameters for waste material may be substances (e.g. cadmium, mercury, lead, salt, PAH), pH, temperature, humidity, compressive strength, grain size, etc. 3.7 programme manager individual responsible for the development of the testing programme (including the sampling plan and the laboratory plan) the execution of the testing programme including the preparation and submission of the final report Note 1 to entry: The programme manager may be directly concerned with the sampling work and/or the laboratory work as employee of a sampling organization and/or a laboratory organization. He/she also may be a ‘third party’ just organizing the whole process and responsible for the final reporting. 3.8 records written and/or electronic files in which, during the sampling procedure, testing procedure, test results, time, place and instruments of testing, and observations are recorded Note 1 to entry: Records (also named testing files or work files) are the basis for calculations and for drafting the final test programme report. The report includes relevant data and observations; usually it is not necessary to include all complete testing files in the final report. It is important that the testing files be available upon request, for example, when in a later stage questions arise on the testing and the testing report. 3.9 sampling plan all the information pertinent to a particular sampling activity Note 1 to entry: The sampling plan includes the taking of the sample, the production of a laboratory sample, and the transport (to the laboratory), and may include the storage of the laboratory sample. Note 2 to entry: In case the measurement can be done directly in the field, transport and storage might not be necessary and then will not be elaborated further in the sampling plan. [SOURCE: EN 14899:2005, 3.18, modified] 3.10 sampling report report providing information on all field activities during waste sampling and including any important observation of the sampler Note 1 to entry: A sampling report is prepared for each sampling operation. Note 2 to entry: Sampling plan and sampling report can both summarize their information in a form, including nearly the same items, which facilitates reporting during the sampling activities and which facilitates comparison of planned activities and the way the sampling was executed. 3.11 testing programme total test operation, from the first step in which the objectives of the test(s) are defined to the last step in which data are analysed and reported Note 1 to entry: The test programme may include analyses of the data, evaluation and statistical treatment of the data and comparison with the legal, scientific or other requirements. Note 2 to entry: A testing programme may include data from several tests with each its own test report, e.g. in production control where each month one batch of one day’s production is tested and the testing programme provides information and conclusions on the performance of the product over the whole of the year. SIST EN 16457:2014



EN 16457:2014 (E) 9
Note 3 to entry: If the test results are to be used for formal evaluation, such as requirements from legislation, permits, certification procedures, the objectives and requirements on the methods to be used may directly come from such formal requirements. Note 4 to entry: The testing programme objectives amongst others include specification of the location and material to be investigated, the scale of material to be tested, the parameters to be investigated, the required reliability, the reference test methods. The objectives of the testing programme need to be specified by the customer. [SOURCE: EN 14899:2005, 3.24, modified] 3.12 testing plan plan, containing both the sampling plan and the laboratory plan 3.13 testing steps main parts of the testing programme which include: 1) defining or further specifying the testing plan, 2) taking the sample, 3) sample preparation, transport to the laboratory and storage, 4) test sample and test portion preparation, 5) required treatment of the test portion, such as extraction, leaching, testing for compressive strength, 6) analysis, quantification, 7) elaborating the overall report Note 1 to entry: For all or most of the steps, specific standardized methods exist or are under development that cover that step as reference method (see 4.5 and Table A.1). Note 2 to entry: In some cases, instructions for different steps are combined in one specific standard, e.g. the extraction and the analysis of substances specified in one test standard. Often a standard on a specific step includes instructions on the final reporting of the results and observations of that step. Note 3 to entry: It might be possible that a number of parameters need to be measured which are covered by different measurement standards; however, the production of the laboratory sample may be the same for all of the parameters. In such cases, all parameters can be covered by a single testing programme. 4 Defining a waste testing programme 4.1 Principles In order to secure reliable and comparable results representative of the tested waste, the testing programme with its objectives shall be based on the following principles: a) the testing programme and its objectives are available before execution tasks are carried out; b) a sampling plan is specified in the testing programme to meet the objective and the sampling sites/locations are identified to enable representative sample(s) to be taken; c) the laboratory testing requirements are specified in the testing plan to ensure acceptance by the laboratory and guarantee that the specified tests can be performed on the samples to be provided; SIST EN 16457:2014



EN 16457:2014 (E)
10
d) the standards specified in this standard and covering the different steps of all processes involved in the testing programme are applied. Other methods may be used in the framework of this standard provided that their comparability/traceability to the standardized methods referred in 4.5 and listed in Annex A is demonstrated in accordance with the testing objectives and with the considered and specific field of application; NOTE 1 Other methods than the ones specified in Annex A may provide adequate information, even if it is not equally precise or if it provides other information, for instance if the performance level of a waste is rather low, compared with a limit value. e) a report of the results is produced which includes all relevant information, including description and justification of any possible deviation from the applied standards; f) competent samplers and competent laboratories are used with clear identification of their responsibilities; NOTE 2 Requirements on the competence of laboratories are specified in EN ISO/IEC 17025 and in the supporting documents (listed in the Introduction). g) competence and responsibilities of the programme manager should be considered / specified before finalizing the testing programme, and where appropriate, should be included in the testing programme. 4.2 Structure of a waste testing programme 4.2.1 First actions and overview of a waste testing programme The first action to be undertaken in a waste testing programme is the specification of the objectives of the testing programme. This also requires the identification of the programme manager (see 4.4). In this first action the objectives of the testing programme are specified by the customer in consultation with the involved parties. All relevant information shall be collected from the involved parties and considered before finalizing the testing programme. NOTE Such involved parties include, for instance, the sampler and/or the analyst and/or the customer and/or the regulator and/or the waste producer. In a second action the testing programme is defined by the programme manager according to the objectives of the testing programme and the relevant/applicable legal requirements. The testing programme contains all relevant information for coordination and describes the relevant steps and actions. It is illustrated in Figure 1 showing an overview of a waste testing programme.
Figure 1 — Overview of a waste testing programme SIST EN 16457:2014



EN 16457:2014 (E) 11
4.2.2 The seven testing steps of a waste testing programme In the field of waste testing, each test consists typically of seven steps: 1) Testing plan (sampling plan and laboratory plan); 2) Taking field sample and production of laboratory sample(s); 3) Packaging, transport and storage (from field to the laboratory); 4) Preparation of test sample and test portion; 5) Leaching, extraction; 6) Analysis, quantification; 7) Overall testing report. In Figure 1, the testing steps 2 and 3 are in the field activities while the testing steps 3, 4, 5 and 6 are in the laboratory activities. In Figure 2, the seven testing steps are shown for testing a single parameter. NOTE 1 Depending on the nature of the parameter to be tested, the testing step 5 is not always performed for instance for density, dry matter …etc. This may also apply to other steps. NOTE 2 A waste testing programme may require the testing of additional parameters, for instance dry matter in order to express the content of a substance in mg/kg on a dry matter basis (see notes in Table A.1). Before the testing programme is designed and executed, the customer appoints a programme manager. The objectives of the testing programme shall be specified by the customer. The testing programme objectives amongst others include specification of the location and material to be investigated, the scale of material to be tested, the parameters to be investigated, the required reliability and the reference test methods. NOTE 3 If the test results are to be used for formal evaluation, such as requirements from legislation, permits, certification procedures, the objectives and requirements on the methods to be used may directly come from such formal requirements. The activities from step 2 up to and including step 6 are recorded in one or more records. These records are written and/or electronic files in which, during the sampling procedure and testing procedure observations such as for instance name, location, used tech
...

SLOVENSKI STANDARD
oSIST prEN 16457:2012
01-oktober-2012
.DUDNWHUL]DFLMDRGSDGNRY2NYLUQRQDYRGLOR]DSULSUDYRLQXSRUDERSURJUDPD
SUHVNXãDQMD&LOMLQDþUWRYDQMHLQSRURþDQMH
Characterization of waste - Framework for the preparation and application of a testing
programme - Objectives, planning and report
Charakterisierung von Abfällen - Rahmen für die Vorbereitung und Anwendung eines
Untersuchungsprogramms - Ziele, Planung und Bericht
Caractérisation des déchets - Procédure-cadre pour l'élaboration et la mise en oeuvre
d'un programme d'essai - Objectifs, planification et rapport
Ta slovenski standard je istoveten z: prEN 16457
ICS:
13.030.01 Odpadki na splošno Wastes in general
oSIST prEN 16457:2012 en,fr,de
2003-01.Slovenski inštitut za standardizacijo. Razmnoževanje celote ali delov tega standarda ni dovoljeno.

---------------------- Page: 1 ----------------------
oSIST prEN 16457:2012

---------------------- Page: 2 ----------------------
oSIST prEN 16457:2012


EUROPEAN STANDARD
DRAFT
prEN 16457
NORME EUROPÉENNE

EUROPÄISCHE NORM

June 2012
ICS 13.030.01
English Version
Characterization of waste - Framework for the preparation and
application of a testing programme - Objectives, planning and
report
Caractérisation des déchets - Procédure-cadre pour Charakterisierung von Abfällen - Rahmen für die
l'élaboration et la mise en oeuvre d'un programme d'essai -
Vorbereitung und Anwendung eines
Objectifs, planification et rapport Untersuchungsprogramms - Ziele, Planung und Bericht
This draft European Standard is submitted to CEN members for enquiry. It has been drawn up by the Technical Committee CEN/TC 292.

If this draft becomes a European Standard, CEN members are bound to comply with the CEN/CENELEC Internal Regulations which
stipulate the conditions for giving this European Standard the status of a national standard without any alteration.

This draft European Standard was established by CEN in three official versions (English, French, German). A version in any other language
made by translation under the responsibility of a CEN member into its own language and notified to the CEN-CENELEC Management
Centre has the same status as the official versions.

CEN members are the national standards bodies of Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia,
Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Iceland, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, Netherlands, Norway, Poland,
Portugal, Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey and United Kingdom.

Recipients of this draft are invited to submit, with their comments, notification of any relevant patent rights of which they are aware and to
provide supporting documentation.

Warning : This document is not a European Standard. It is distributed for review and comments. It is subject to change without notice and
shall not be referred to as a European Standard.


EUROPEAN COMMITTEE FOR STANDARDIZATION
COMITÉ EUROPÉEN DE NORMALISATION

EUROPÄISCHES KOMITEE FÜR NORMUNG

Management Centre: Avenue Marnix 17, B-1000 Brussels
© 2012 CEN All rights of exploitation in any form and by any means reserved Ref. No. prEN 16457:2012: E
worldwide for CEN national Members.

---------------------- Page: 3 ----------------------
oSIST prEN 16457:2012
prEN 16457:2012 (E)
Contents Page
Foreword .3
Introduction .4
1 Scope .5
2 Normative references .5
3 Terms and definitions.7
4 Defining a waste testing programme .9
4.1 Principles .9
4.2 Structure of a waste testing programme .10
4.2.1 First actions and overview of a waste testing programme .10
4.2.2 The seven testing steps of a waste testing programme .11
4.3 Parameters to be tested for a waste .12
4.4 Responsibilities and programme manager .13
4.5 Standards to be used .14
5 Carrying out a waste testing programme .15
6 Overall testing report .15
Annex A (normative) Matrix testing steps versus parameters specifying the standards to be used in a
waste testing programme .17
Annex B (informative) Overview of the three documents under development supporting the present
European Standard .21
B.1 Application of EN ISO/IEC 17025 to waste testing (CEN/TS – WI292bbb) .21
B.2 Guidelines for the elaboration of standardised testing methods for waste testing (CEN/TS –
WI292ccc) .21
B.3 General information on content tests and leaching tests (CEN/TR – WI292ddd). .22
Bibliography .24

2

---------------------- Page: 4 ----------------------
oSIST prEN 16457:2012
prEN 16457:2012 (E)
Foreword
This document (prEN 16457:2012) has been prepared by Technical Committee CEN/TC 292 “Characterization of
waste”, the secretariat of which is held by NEN.
This document is currently submitted to the CEN Enquiry.
This document has been prepared by the ad hoc group "Testing programme" of CEN/TC 292. It has been decided
by CEN/TC 292 to prepare the present document and to consider separately other issues supporting this document.
This would finally result in a set of four documents on waste testing as listed in the introduction.

3

---------------------- Page: 5 ----------------------
oSIST prEN 16457:2012
prEN 16457:2012 (E)
Introduction
This European Standard was elaborated as a help for whom has to organise and apply a waste testing programme.
Often several parameters are to be determined in a waste sample. Also for each parameter different testing steps
of different nature are to be coordinated and performed. This is done in accordance with dedicated standards
developed by CEN/TC 292 (e.g. standards for the steps of sampling, extraction, leaching and analysis of eluates or
extracts). In order to cope with these different parameters to be tested and with these different testing steps of
different nature, the testing of a waste generally refers to different standards which should be used (and elaborated)
in a coherent and coordinated way in a testing programme. This European Standard is designed for specifying such
overall testing programmes.
This European Standard may be used by different interested parties in waste testing: plant operators, testing
institutes, accreditation bodies, etc. But also by industries to address the waste testing part of their contracts and by
regulators to address the waste testing part of their regulations. This European Standard can be used to:
 produce standardised testing programme for use in regular or routine circumstances (elaboration of
daughter/derived standards dedicated to well defined testing scenarios);
 incorporate the specific testing requirements of European and national legislation;
 design and develop a waste testing programme for use on a case by case basis.
This European Standard provides requirements on the programme, objective, plan and report for the execution of a
waste testing programme. This is done with the intent to ensure reliable and comparable results when using the
reference methods that have been developed by CEN/TC 292 in accordance with the principles specified in this
standard and in the supporting documents (listed below).
As shown in figures 2 and 3, for waste testing, the tests to be performed consist (see also the supporting
documents listed below) of two main works, the sampling in the field and the analysis-quantification in the
laboratory. The needed coordination and interface is the responsibility of the programme manager (see sub-clause
4.4). It is also the responsibility of the programme manager to design the testing programme, to sign the testing
report and to submit it to the customer.
This European Standard includes two normative annexes and one informative annex which are part of this
standard. This European Standard is intended to become a part of a set of documents consisting of the present
document:
 prEN 16457, Characterization of waste – Framework for the preparation and application of a testing
programme – Objective, planning and report
and of three supporting documents providing important information and for which an overview is given in the
informative Annex C of the present European Standard:
 CEN/TS (WI 292bbb), Characterization of waste – Framework for the preparation and application of a testing
programme – Application of EN ISO/IEC 17025 (in preparation)
 CEN/TS (WI 292ccc), Characterization of waste – Framework for the preparation and application of a testing
programme – Guidelines for the elaboration of standardized testing methods (in preparation)
 CEN/TR (WI 292ddd), Characterization of waste – Framework for the preparation and application of a testing
programme – General information on content tests and leaching tests (in preparation)
4

---------------------- Page: 6 ----------------------
oSIST prEN 16457:2012
prEN 16457:2012 (E)
1 Scope
This European Standard specifies requirements for a waste testing programme regarding mainly objectives,
planning and report with the intent to ensure reliable and comparable results when using the reference methods that
have been developed and/or adopted by CEN/TC 292.
The planning and report aspects of this European Standard are applicable to any waste testing programme
dedicated to the determination of one or several parameters. They are also applicable to all testing steps for each
parameter from sampling up to reporting whether these steps are taking place in the field (e.g. sampling) or in the
laboratory (e.g. analysis-quantification).
NOTE The term planning a testing programme is used here with the general meaning of organizing a testing programme
and being in accordance with the terms testing plan, sampling plan, laboratory plan used in the present European Standard
This European Standard does not address aspects of safety for activities in the field and inside laboratory.
2 Normative references
The following documents, in whole or in part, are normatively referenced in this document and are indispensable for
its application. For dated references, only the edition cited applies. For undated references, the latest edition of the
referenced document (including any amendments) applies.
EN 12457-1:2002, Characterisation of waste – Leaching – Compliance test for leaching of granular waste materials
and sludges – Part 1: One stage batch test at a liquid to solid ratio of 2 l/kg for materials with high solid content and
with particle size below 4 mm (without or with size reduction)
EN 12457-2:2002, Characterisation of waste – Leaching – Compliance test for leaching of granular waste materials
and sludges – Part 2: One stage batch test at a liquid to solid ratio of 10 l/kg for materials with particle size below 4
mm (without or with size reduction)
EN 12457-3:2002, Characterisation of waste – Leaching – Compliance test for leaching of granular waste materials
and sludges – Part 3: Two stage batch test at a liquid to solid ratio of 2 l/kg and 8 l/kg for materials with high solid
content and with particle size below 4 mm (without or with size reduction)
EN 12457-4:2002, Characterisation of waste – Leaching – Compliance test for leaching of granular waste materials
and sludges – Part 4: One stage batch test at a liquid to solid ratio of 10 l/kg for materials with particle size below 10
mm (without or with size reduction)
EN 13137:2001, Characterization of waste – Determination of total organic carbon (TOC) in waste, sludges and
sediments
EN 13656:2002, Characterization of waste – Microwave assisted digestion with hydrofluoric (HF), nitric (HNO ) and
3
hydrochloric (HCl) acid mixture for subsequent determination of elements
EN 13657:2002, Characterization of waste – Digestion for subsequent determination of aqua regia soluble portion of
elements
EN 14039:2004, Characterization of waste – Determination of hydrocarbon content in the range of C10 to C40 by
gas chromatography
EN 14345:2004, Characterization of waste – Determination of hydrocarbon content by gravimetry
EN 14346:2006, Characterization of waste – Calculation of dry matter by determination of dry residue or water
content
CEN/TS 14405:2004, Characterization of waste – Leaching behaviour tests – Up-flow percolation test (under
specified conditions)
5

---------------------- Page: 7 ----------------------
oSIST prEN 16457:2012
prEN 16457:2012 (E)
CEN/TS 14429:2005, Characterization of waste – Leaching behaviour tests – Influence of pH on leaching with initial
acid/base addition
EN 14582:2007, Characterization of waste – Halogen and sulfur content – Oxygen combustion in closed systems
and determination methods
EN 14735:2005, Characterization of waste – Preparation of waste samples for ecotoxicity tests
EN 14899:2005, Characterization of waste – Sampling of waste materials – Framework for the preparation and
application of a sampling plan
CEN/TS 14997:2006, Characterization of waste – Leaching behaviour tests – Influence of pH on leaching with
continuous pH-control
EN 15002:2006, Characterization of waste – Preparation of test portions from the laboratory sample
EN 15169:2007, Characterization of waste – Determination of loss on ignition in waste, sludge and sediments
EN 15192:2006, Characterisation of waste and soil – Determination of Chromium(VI) in solid material by alkaline
digestion and ion chromatography with spectrophotometric detection
EN 15308:2008, Characterization of waste – Determination of selected polychlorinated biphenyls (PCB) in solid
waste by using capillary gas chromatography with electron capture or mass spectrometric detection
EN 15309:2007, Characterization of waste and soil – Determination of elemental composition by X-ray fluorescence
EN 15216:2007, Characterization of waste – Determination of total dissolved solids (TDS) in water and eluates
CEN/TS 15364:2006, Characterization of waste – Leaching behaviour tests – Acid and base neutralization capacity
test
EN 15527:2008, Characterization of waste – Determination of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH) in waste
using gas chromatography mass spectrometry (GC/MS)
CEN/TS 15862, Characterization of waste – Compliance leaching test – One stage batch leaching test for monoliths
at fixed liquid to surface area ratio (L/A) for test portions with fixed minimum dimensions
CEN/TS 15863, Characterization of waste – Leaching behaviour test for basic characterization – Dynamic
monolithic leaching test with periodic leachant renewal, under fixed test conditions
CEN/TS 15864, Characterization of waste – Leaching behaviour test for basic characterization – Dynamic
monolithic leaching test with continuous leachant renewal under conditions relevant for specified scenario(s)
EN 15875:2011, Characterization of waste – Static test for determination of acid potential of sulfidic waste
prEN 16023, Characterization of waste – Determination of gross calorific value and calculation of net calorific value
EN 16192:2011, Characterization of waste – Analysis of eluates
CEN/TS 16229:2011, Characterization of waste – Sampling and analysis of weak acid dissociable cyanide
discharged into tailings ponds
prEN 16377, Characterization of waste – Determination of brominated flame retardants (BFR) in solid waste
NOTE Useful information may be found in several CEN/TR as mentioned in Annex A. The use of CEN/TRs is not
mandatory and other sources of information may be used provided that the requirements of the basic EN or CEN/TS are
fulfilled. The list of such CEN/TR is as follows:
 CEN/TR 15018:2005, Characterization of waste – Digestion of waste samples using alkali-fusion techniques
6

---------------------- Page: 8 ----------------------
oSIST prEN 16457:2012
prEN 16457:2012 (E)
 CEN/TR 15310-1:2006, Characterization of waste – Sampling of waste materials – Part 1: Guidance on
selection and application of criteria for sampling under various conditions
 CEN/TR 15310-2:2006, Characterization of waste – Sampling of waste materials – Part 2: Guidance on
sampling techniques
 CEN/TR 15310-3:2006, Characterization of waste – Sampling of waste materials – Part 3: Guidance on
procedures for sub-sampling in the field
 CEN/TR 15310-4:2006, Characterization of waste – Sampling of waste materials – Part 4: Guidance on
procedures for sample packaging, storage, preservation, transport and delivery
 CEN/TR 15310-5:2006, Characterization of waste – Sampling of waste materials – Part 5: Guidance on the
process of defining the sampling plan
 CEN/TR 16110:2010, Characterization of waste – Guidance on the use of ecotoxicity tests applied to waste
 CEN/TR 16130:2011, Characterization of waste – On-site verification
 CEN/TR 16176:2011, Characterization of waste – Screening methods for elemental composition by X-ray
fluorescence spectrometry for on-site verification
 FprCEN/TR 16363:2011, Characterization of waste – Kinetic testing for assessing acid generation potential of
sulfidic waste from extractive industries
 FprCEN/TR 16365:2012, Characterization of waste – Sampling of waste from extractive industries

3 Terms and definitions
The terms and definitions listed in this clause are needed for the present European Standard with regards to the
design and execution of a testing programme. In many other standardized documents useful terms and definitions
are available and these will not be repeated here.
NOTE The supporting document Guidelines for the elaboration of standardized testing methods (in preparation) referred
to in the introduction would consolidate and harmonise the definitions in all CEN/TC 292 standards.
3.1
testing programme
total test operation, from the first step in which the objectives of the test(s) are defined to the last step in which data
are analysed and reported. The test programme may include analyses of the data, evaluation and statistical
treatment of the data and comparison with the legal, scientific or other requirements.
[derived from EN 14899 – 3.24]
Note 1 to entry: A testing programme may include data from several tests with each its own test report, e.g. in production
control where each month one batch of one day’s production is tested and the testing programme provides information and
conclusions on the performance of the product over the whole of the year.
Note 2 to entry: If the test results are to be used for formal evaluation, such as requirements from legislation, permits,
certification procedures, the objectives and requirements on the methods to be used may directly come from such formal
requirements.
Note 3 to entry: The testing programme objectives among others include specification of the location and material to be
investigated, the scale of material to be tested, the parameters to be investigated, the required reliability, the reference test
methods. The objectives of the testing programme have to be specified by the customer.
3.2
testing plan
plan, containing both the sampling plan and the laboratory plan.
7

---------------------- Page: 9 ----------------------
oSIST prEN 16457:2012
prEN 16457:2012 (E)

3.3
sampling plan
all the information pertinent to a particular sampling activity.
[SOURCE: EN 14899, 3.18 and ISO 11074-2]

Note 1 to entry: The sampling plan includes the taking of the sample, the production of a laboratory sample, and the
transport (to the laboratory), and may include the storage of the laboratory sample.
Note 2 to entry: In case the measurement can be done directly in the field, transport and storage might not be necessary
and then will not be elaborated further in the sampling plan.
3.4
sampling report
report providing information on all field activities during waste sampling and including any important observation of
the sampler.
Note 1 to entry: A sampling report is prepared for each sampling operation.
Note 2 to entry: Sampling plan and sampling report can both summarize their information in a form, including nearly the
same items, which facilitates reporting during the sampling activities and which facilitates comparison of planned activities and
the way the sampling was executed.
3.5
laboratory plan
plan, part of the testing plan, including all the required steps and relevant information pertinent to a particular
laboratory activity.

Note 1 to entry: The laboratory plan includes the preparation of the test sample(s), the extraction, leaching or other activity
with the sample(s), analysis, calculations and reporting.
Note 2 to entry: The laboratory plan includes specification of the tests to be executed, the laboratory (or laboratories)
involved, and the planning.
3.6
records
written and/or electronic files in which, during the sampling procedure, testing procedure, test results, time, place
and instruments of testing, and observations are recorded.

Note 1 to entry: Records (also named testing files or work files) are the basis for calculations and for drafting the final test
programme report. Relevant data and observations should be included in the report. Usually it is not necessary to include all
complete testing files in the final report. The testing files should be available upon request for example when in a later stage
questions arise on the testing and the testing report.
3.7
testing steps
steps parts of the testing programme. The main steps in a testing programme are (1) defining or further specifying
the testing plan, (2) taking the sample, (3) sample preparation, transport to the laboratory and storage, (4) test
portion preparation, (5) required treatment of the laboratory sample, such as extraction, leaching, testing for
compressive strength, (6) analysis, quantification, (7) elaborating the overall report.

Note 1 to entry: For all or most of the steps specific standardized methods exist or are under development that cover that
step as reference method (see sub-clause 4.5 and table in Annex A).
Note 2 to entry: In some cases instructions for different steps are combined in one specific standard, e.g. the extraction and
the analysis of substances specified in one test standard. Often a standard on a specific step includes instructions on the final
reporting of the results and observations of that step.
Note 3 to entry: It might be possible that a number of parameters have to be measured, covered by different measurement
standards, however the production of the laboratory sample may be the same for all of the parameters. In such case all
parameters can be covered by a single testing programme.
8

---------------------- Page: 10 ----------------------
oSIST prEN 16457:2012
prEN 16457:2012 (E)
3.8
involved parties
individuals and organisations that are directly or indirectly involved in the specification of the testing programme and
or in the execution of the programme.
[adapted from EN 14899 – 2.7]

Note 1 to entry: Such parties include, for instance, the customer, (e.g. the producer or the user of the material), the
regulator, a certification body, the sampler, the analyst, the laboratory. The person responsible for the final specification of the
testing programme and the final test report is the programme manager.
3.9
customer
organisation or person that orders for a test and that receives the final test report
[derived from EN ISO 9000]

3.10
programme manager
individual responsible for the development of the testing programme (including the sampling plan and the laboratory
plan) the execution of the testing programme including the preparation and submission of the final report.

Note 1 to entry: The programme manager may be directly concerned with the sampling work and/or the laboratory work as
employee of a sampling organisation and/or a laboratory organisation. He/she also may be a ‘third party’ just organising the
whole process and responsible for the final reporting.
3.11
parameter
a measurable property whose value is a determinant of the characteristics of a waste material.

Note 1 to entry: For instance relevant parameters for waste material may be substances (like cadmium, mercury, lead, salt,
PAH), pH, temperature, humidity, compressive strength, grain size, ….etc.
3.12
additional parameter (AP)
parameter that shall be tested so that the test results could be calculated and/or interpreted.

Note 1 to entry: For instance the dry matter for expressing the test results on a dry basis, or pH in eluate to be able to
understand and check consistency of test data and to understand/investigate unexpected outcome or unexpected variations.
3.13
analysis / quantification
step in the testing programme where the magnitude of the parameters is determined and the obtained data can be
directly delivered for final use and reporting or from which the data can be delivered for further calculations.

Note 1 to entry: For instance measuring the length with a measuring tape, measuring the temperature with a thermometer,
determining (analysing) the concentrations of substances in an extract or eluate. In the last example the concentration of the
substance in a material or the leachable fraction from a material should be calculated, using the data on the concentrations in
the extract or the eluate.
4 Defining a waste testing programme
4.1 Principles
In order to secure reliable and comparable results representative of the tested waste, the testing programme with its
objectives shall be based on the following principles:
a) the testing programme and its objectives are available before execution tasks are carried out;
b) a sampling plan is specified in the testing programme to meet the objective and the sampling sites/locations
are identified to enable representative sample(s) to be taken;
9

---------------------- Page: 11 ----------------------
oSIST prEN 16457:2012
prEN 16457:2012 (E)
c) the laboratory testing requirements are specified in the testing plan to ensure acceptance by the laboratory and
guarantee that the specified tests can be performed on the samples to be provided;
d) the standards specified in this standard and covering the different steps of all processes involved in the testing
programme are applied. Other methods may be used in the framework of this standard provided that their
comparability/traceability to the standardised methods referred in 4.5 and listed in Annex A is demonstrated in
accordance with the testing objectives and with the considered and specific field of application;
NOTE 1 Other methods than the ones specified in Annex A may provide adequate information, even if it is not equally
precise or if it provides other information, for instance if the performance level of a waste is rather low, compared with a
limit value.
e) a report of the results is produced which includes all relevant information, including description and justification
of any possible deviation from the applied standards;
f) competent samplers and competent laboratories are used with clear identification of their responsibilities;
NOTE 2 Requirements on the competence of laboratories are specified in EN ISO/IEC 17025 and in the supporting
documents (listed in the introduction).
g) competence and responsibilities of the programme manager should be considered / specified before finalizing
the testing programme, and where appropriate, should be included in the testing programme.
4.2 Structure of a waste testing programme
4.2.1 First actions and overview of a waste testing programme
The first action to be undertaken in a waste testing programme is the specification of the objectives of the testing
programme. This also requires the identification of the programme manager (see 4.4).
In t
...

Questions, Comments and Discussion

Ask us and Technical Secretary will try to provide an answer. You can facilitate discussion about the standard in here.